Under construction

YANKEE LAKE


A 400-Acre Spring-Fed Lake With Deep Historical Roots, Strong Community Governance, and One of the Best Locations in Sullivan County


Yankee Lake, located in Wurtsboro, NY, is one of the oldest and most historically significant lake communities in Sullivan County and one of the largest. Originally engineered in the 19th century to supply water to the Delaware & Hudson Canal with a rich history as a retreat for broadway stars of its golden era, the lake spans roughly 400 acres, with depths ranging from shallow coves to pockets reaching 40 feet.


Over the decades, the community around Yankee Lake evolved from scattered deeded lake users into a fully organized and well-managed association known as the Yankee Lake Preservation Association (YLPA). Today, Yankee Lake is one of the most desirable electric-motor lakes in the region, known for its water quality, continuity, and highly engaged community culture.

 
Overview

  • Location: Wurtsboro, NY (Town of Mamakating)
  • Distance to NYC: ~90 minutes
  • Lake Size: ~400 acres
  • Lake Type: Electric motor only
  • Depth: Average ~8 ft, with deeper pockets up to ~40 ft
  • Community Type: Private lake with formal association (YLPA)
  • Historical Origin: 19th-century engineered reservoir for the D&H Canal


Yankee Lake offers scale, stability, and stewardship in equal measure.



Water & Recreation


As a large, electric-motor lake, Yankee Lake supports a wide range of quiet recreation:



  • Electric boating
  • Kayaking & canoeing
  • Paddleboarding
  • Swimming
  • Fishing
  • Skating and winter use when conditions allow

Because motorboats are not permitted, the lake remains calm, clean, and safe, especially appealing for families and long-term residents.

 


Community Structure


The Yankee Lake Preservation Association (YLPA) is the centerpiece of the community:


  • YLPA owns the lake itself, a rare achievement that ensures long-term control over its future
  • The association maintains the clubhouse, and community events
  • Roads and lake access points are well cared for
  • A strong calendar of activities helps sustain community cohesion


YLPA governance is considered one of the strongest in Sullivan County, both in structure and resident participation.

 


Architecture & Homes


Yankee Lake offers a mix of home styles:


  • Classic Catskills lake cottages
  • Renovated mid-century homes
  • Modernized lakefront residences
  • Year-round homes with lake views
  • Quiet side roads with small clusters of homes
  • A range of lot sizes, from small seasonal parcels to more conventional full-size lots


The lake’s long history produces a visually interesting, highly livable shoreline.

 


Setting & Surroundings


Yankee Lake sits in one of the most geographically advantageous parts of the county:


  • Minutes from NY-17, making it one of the fastest-access lake communities from NYC
  • Close to Wurtsboro, with shops, cafés, and restaurants
  • Near the Basha Kill Wetlands, ideal for birdwatching, paddling, and photography
  • A short drive to Rock Hill, Monticello, and the southern lake corridor
  • Forested surroundings that buffer the lake from noise and traffic
  • This balance of accessibility and natural quiet is a major long-term value driver.

 


Who Yankee Lake Is Right For


Yankee Lake is ideal for buyers who want:


  • A large, electric-motor-only lake with clean water
  • A strong, organized, and highly functional lake association
  • A stable community with a long history and active membership
  • A quiet lake environment close to NYC
  • A mix of seasonal and year-round homes
  • Amenities such as a clubhouse and community events
  • A lake that feels substantial without sacrificing peace


Listings

More